In anticipation of anti-piracy recommendations to be issued by the European Commission “in November,” the Audiovisual Anti-Piracy Alliance (AAPA) has issued a plea for a three-layered approach toward site blocking.
Live broadcast piracy in Europe is growing, not receding. In November 2025 the European Commission found that it had not delivered the improvement it sought via Recommendation (EU) 2023/1018, toward mitigating piracy in the EU.
The EC assessment was direct: “Despite the progress made, the Recommendation has not resulted in considerable curbing of the overall level of piracy of live events. The assessment highlights in particular the lack of an effective treatment of notices by some categories of hosting service providers as well as the reluctance of certain intermediaries to cooperate with rightholders.
Evolving recognition
In May 2026, the European Commission put out a call for input, toward a formal recommendation to be issued “in November.” The Audiovisual Anti-Piracy Alliance (AAPA) proposed an ecosystem, the critical role of hosting providers and European ICT, and the regulatory gaps, in the EU’s Call for Evidence in its review of copyright rules.
In July, the European Parliament explained how live-content piracy had matured into a structured and economically resilient segment of the piracy ecosystem; particularly in relation to sports broadcasting.recommended the establishment of immediate notice-and-takedown mechanisms in each EU member state that is binding upon downstream intermediaries such as DNS resolvers, CDNs and VPN providers.
AAPA’s updated recommendation
The EC extended the comment period to November 10, and is now in the process of digesting that input, and preparing its recommendations. In its comments, AAPA proposed an updated program with three components:
• Layer A — Notice and takedown that works at live speed. A binding obligation on hosting providers to remove live pirated content as near to immediately as is reasonably and/or technically achievable and, in any event, within 30 minutes of a valid notice, with meaningful stay-down measures, effective supervision and deterrent sanctions for systematic non-compliance.
• Layer B — Consequenes for those who will not comply. A competent authority designates the networks of hosting providers that persistently fail to act on notices and whose networks are predominantly used for piracy and other illegal content. The designation is entered in a live Union- wide register and, on publication, triggers binding obligations on providers established in, or offering services in, the Union not to serve the designated operator in respect of those resources or carry traffic to them.
• Layer C — A dynamic live blocking backstop in every EU Member State. AAPA implores the EU to require a mechanism for live content that meets common minimum principles and a binding capability test at EU level. Whatever institutional route a Member State chooses, the mechanism must be capable of adding and updating verified targets within the live window, without a fresh application for each event or target, while preserving effective review and redress.
The three measures are cumulative, not alternatives. Lack of timely takedown needs a consequence; the consequence needs a defined standard of non-compliance to attach to; both need a backstop. Adopt one without the others and the problem stays where it is.
Why it matters
As of this writing, the EU’s recommendations are pending. A 30-minute blocking requirement is well-intentioned, but Italy’s Piracy Shield and other blocking regimens show that blocking requires nuance and fine-tuning, lest the wrong parties be blocked, and decide to exit the market.
But while site blocking has proven effective in reducing illegal distribution and it’s a good start, it’s a conversation that began as much as a decade ago. Meanwhile, the piracy problem continues to evolve: piracy has gone from infringing access to premium video accounts to piracy-as-a-service, and now, has metastacized not only into a threat against every segment of the content creation, distribution and consumption ecosystem, but also as a threat to personal agency and as a weapon of nation-state actors.
Further reading
Live broadcast piracy in Europe: The case for a three-layered regulatory response. Position paper. October 2026. Press release November 17, 2026. Audiovisual Anti-piracy Alliance (AAPA)
EU Assessment: Rapid piracy blocking comes up short for sports and broadcast. Article. July 30, 2026. by Steven Hawley. Piracy Monitor
European Commission seeks input now, to improve anti-piracy recommendations in November. Article. May 2, 2026. by Steven Hawley. Piracy Monitor
European Commission releases Asssessment of 2023 Piracy Recommendation, but no new recommendations. Article. November 20, 2025. by Steven Hawley. Piracy Monitor










