Dutch man watched torrents for 24 years without copyright warning. Then he switched to Starlink

Sponsor ad - 728w x 90h (at 72 dpi)

Czechia’s Association of Commercial Television (AKTV) reported that a Dutch flight instructor had been obtaining TV content via torrent for 24 years without ever receiving a copyright infringement warning from his Internet service provider. That was until he used the Starlink broadband service to download an episode of Dexter: Resurrection.

On November 1, the man shared a message via social media revealing that Starlink had forwarded him a copyright infringement notice from Paramount, just two days after he downloaded the episode.

Piracy Monitor Supporter

Starlink has been issuing copyright infringement notices since 2021, and its terms of service explicitly prohibit using the connection for the illegal distribution of copyrighted content. Repeated violations can result in the suspension or permanent termination of internet service.

The violator had been operating all this time under the assumption that Dutch Internet providers automatically protect all their customers. But in May 2023, a Dutch appeals court ruled in a case that an internet provider must forward a warning from the anti-piracy organisation BREIN to one of its customers

Why it matters

There are interesting questions here.  First, BitTorrent technology is not illegal, but distribution of copyrighted content that happened to be obtained that way is. There was no indication that the user was pro-actively re-distributing the content, but BitTorrent’s technology enables the user’s computer for distribution to others.

Also, the offender reportedly planned to use a VPN for the remaining month of his subscription before switching to a Dutch internet provider. Until then, the incident had resulted only in a warning, rather than a fine or service disconnection. So he decided that it was OK to continue, but to hide his activity within a VPN.

But the other question goes to whether a consumer of content obtained without license or legitimate distibution is considered to be a pirate. Under EU and Dutch law, if it’s for private use (“fair use”), it is considered a civil – not criminal – offense.

Further reading

He downloaded torrents for 24 years without issues. Then he used Starlink and received a copyright warning.  Article. November 4, 2026. Association of Commercial Television, Czechia / Czech Republic

 

 

From our Sponsors